One of the most controversial incidents in cricket’s history was the Monkeygate scandal. Two of the biggest names in cricket, Harbhajan Singh and Andrew Symonds, were involved in the incident, which occurred during the second Test match between India and Australia in Sydney in 2008.
Monkeygate Scandal: The Incident
During the second Test match between Australia and India in Sydney in 2008, controversy broke out Due to several controversial decisions made in favour of Australia by on-field umpire Steve Bucknor. Despite this, India had a strong showing in their batting innings, with centuries from Sachin Tendulkar and VVS Laxman, as well as a courageous fifty by Sourav Ganguly. However, a disagreement between Australian batsman Andrew Symonds and Indian spinner Harbhajan Singh during the 116th over of India’s innings led in a shocking revelation.
After a quick delivery from Brett Lee, Harbhajan walked over to Symonds and exchanged some words with him. Harbhajan was warned by on-field umpire Mark Benson after this first normal interaction soon turned into a disaster. The Australian team complained that Harbhajan had called Symonds a “monkey” in a racist slur.
Symonds, who is of West Indian descent, tried to claim that Harbhajan called him a “monkey” during the match, which Symonds mistook for a racial slur. After a heated conversation between the two players, Symonds informed match referee Mike Procter of the incident.
The racial abuse charges sparked controversy in the cricketing community, with the Indian team and their supporters standing up for Harbhajan and denying the allegations. On the other hand, the Australian team backed Symonds and called for Harbhajan to be punished.
Investigation and Decision
The International Cricket Council (ICC) followed the matter into consideration and appointed a three-member panel to investigate the incident. The panel was made up of former Sri Lankan cricketer Ranjan Madugalle, ICC match referee Mike Procter, and ICC CEO Malcolm Speed.
The panel held a hearing which lasted two days during which it reviewed all of the parties’ testimony. After giving it considerable thought, the panel concluded that Harbhajan had racially disrespected Symonds and handed him a three-match ban.
The decision of the panel was met with mixed reactions from the cricketing community. The Indian team and its supporters were furious and accused the panel of bias while the Australian team and its supporters praised the decision.
The incident brought attention to the problem of racism in cricket and sparked a debate on how to handle similar incidents in the future. The incident also highlighted the problem of cultural differences between international teams and players.
Monkeygate Scandal: Appeal Hearing and Reversal of Decision
Indian skipper, Anil Kumble and Co. refused to continue with the tour until the decision was overturned. The situation got to the point where the Indian government had to intervene to stabilize the situation. The Indian government threatened to cancel the tour if the ICC did not change its decision.
The ICC held an emergency meeting and decided to suspend the ban until the appeal hearing was finished. The appeal hearing was held in Adelaide and was ruled over by New Zealand High Court Judge John Hansen.
The Indian team presented video evidence during the appeal hearing to prove that Harbhajan did not actually say the term “Monkey,” but rather the Hindi word “Teri Maa Ki”. The video proof also revealed that Symonds had provoked Harbhajan by using abusive language.
After a long hearing on the appeal, which lasted more than six hours, the decision was overturned. The charges against Harbhajan were dismissed, and the ban was lifted. Nevertheless, the Indian spinner was fined 50% of the match fee.
Consequences of the Incident
The incident had major consequences for the participating teams and players. Symonds, who had already been dropped from the Australian team due to his poor performance, became even more separated from the team and never played for Australia again. In addition, Harbhajan’s reputation deteriorated and he was largely viewed as racist.
The relationship between the two countries was affected by the incident as well. The Indian team alleged that the Australians had been racist as they had treated them unfairly. The two teams’ relationship was strained by the incident, and it took some time for it to rebuild.
Impact on the ICC Code of Conduct
The incident also caused the ICC code of conduct to change, demanding all players treat one another with respect and refrain from any actions that could be interpreted as racist or discriminatory.
Overall, there have been several controversies in cricket over the years but the Monkeygate scandal was the most shocking controversy in cricket because it involved allegations of racial discrimination, which is a highly sensitive issue in any sport.
Also, it caused a major conflict between the Australian and Indian teams, with each side accusing the other of behaving inappropriately. Broad media coverage of the incident and the subsequent discussion about racism in cricket led to tougher rules and penalties for such offences.
Also Read: Pakistan vs New Zealand 2023: Schedule, Squads and Live Streaming
